Temporal

Overview

Temporal is considered a Distributed Systems because it is architected to coordinate long-running, fault-tolerant workflows across multiple machines in a reliable and scalable way. Here’s a breakdown of why Temporal qualifies as a distributed system:

✅ 1. Multiple Components Running Across Nodes

Temporal is composed of several components:

Frontend service (handles gRPC requests)
History service (maintains workflow state)
Matching service (schedules tasks to workers)
Worker service (executes application logic) These services are typically deployed across different machines or containers, forming a distributed system.

✅ 2. Workflow Execution is Distributed

Workflows in Temporal:

Are stateful, long-lived (minutes to months)
Execute across different worker processes, which can be on different machines
Survive worker crashes and resume elsewhere

This requires distributed coordination.

✅ 3. Resilient and Fault-Tolerant

Temporal ensures:

Durability through persistent storage (e.g., Cassandra, MySQL, Postgres)
Failover and retry mechanisms for tasks
Deterministic replay of workflow history to recover state

These features require a distributed architecture to achieve high availability and fault isolation.

✅ 4. Horizontal Scalability

You can scale each component of Temporal independently:

Add more workers to handle more tasks
Add more frontend or history nodes to handle more workflows

Scalability across machines = distributed system.

✅ 5. Communication via Network Calls

Temporal services and workers communicate via gRPC over the network—another hallmark of a distributed system.

In Summary:

Temporal is a distributed system because it consists of multiple services running on different nodes, coordinating over a network to execute and manage workflows reliably, with fault-tolerance, persistence, and scalability.

Idempotency In Temporal

Temporal ensures Idempotency automatically by:

Replaying deterministic workflow code
Not re-executing side effects (e.g., activities) unless marked as retryable
Letting you manage external side effects with activity retries and versioning

This is one reason why Temporal workflows are reliable and fault-tolerant.

Concurrency in Temporal

Temporal provides safe Concurrency:

Multiple workflows can run in parallel
Workflows themselves are single-threaded and deterministic
Activities (external tasks) can run in parallel or be throttled
Signals and queries can be sent concurrently to workflows

This lets you build systems that scale, recover from failure, and remain consistent.

Asynchrony in Temporal

Temporal is inherently asynchronous:

Workflows can call activities asynchronously, allowing parallel execution.
Timers, signals, and child workflows are non-blocking.
Even though workflows look synchronous (sequential code), Temporal asynchronously manages state, retries, and execution under the hood.

Example (pseudo-code):

# Sequential but non-blocking: runs in parallel
a = await workflow.execute_activity(send_email)
b = await workflow.execute_activity(log_to_audit)

Even though this looks linear, Temporal can run the activities in parallel behind the scenes.

Determinism in Temporal

Temporal replays workflow code from event history to restore state after restarts or crashes. To make this possible:

Workflow code must be deterministic
Non-deterministic behavior (e.g., Date.now(), random numbers, external calls) must be isolated inside Activities, not inside workflows

✅ Good (Deterministic) Workflow Example:

# This is safe: uses fixed inputs
result = await workflow.execute_activity(add, 3, 5)

❌ Bad (Non-deterministic) Workflow Example:

# BAD: result changes on every replay!
now = datetime.now()

Instead, you should:

# GOOD: use Temporal APIs for time
now = workflow.now()

🧠 How Temporal Enforces Determinism

It records a history of all events (activity calls, timers, signals, etc.)
When recovering, it re-executes the workflow code from the beginning, using that history to ensure behavior matches exactly
Any divergence = non-determinism error

💡 Key Sources of Non-Determinism to Avoid

Current time (datetime.now())
Randomness (random())
External API calls
Multithreading and shared state
Switch/case on dynamic values

🔐 How to Stay Deterministic

Use Temporal’s built-in APIs (workflow.now(), workflow.uuid4())
Keep side-effects in Activities, not in the workflow code
Don’t use global mutable state inside workflows
Avoid concurrency inside workflows (Temporal executes them single-threaded)

Summary

Feature	Deterministic Workflow	Non-Deterministic Workflow
✅ Reliable replay	✅	❌
✅ Safe retrying	✅	❌
✅ Debuggable	✅	❌

Workflow in Temporal?

A workflow in Temporal is a deterministic, stateful function that orchestrates the execution of activities (units of external work), timers, child workflows, and signals/queries over time—possibly running for minutes to months while handling failures, retries, and restarts automatically.

🧠 Core Properties of Temporal Workflows

Property	Description
Deterministic	Must always produce the same result when replayed
Durable	State is persisted to survive crashes/restarts
Fault-tolerant	Automatically restarts after worker failure
Event-driven	Can respond to signals, timers, and external events
Orchestration-focused	Coordinates multiple async tasks (activities/workflows)

📦 What Workflows Can Do

Call and coordinate activities (e.g., send email, process payment)
Sleep/timer logic without blocking resources
Wait for external signals
Spawn child workflows
Handle retries, versioning, cancellations
Maintain business state over time

🧱 Workflow Structure (High-Level)

# Python SDK Example (simplified)
@workflow.defn
class MyWorkflow:
    @workflow.run
    async def run(self, name: str) -> str:
        result = await workflow.execute_activity(send_email, name)
        await workflow.sleep(3600)  # wait 1 hour
        return f"Workflow completed for {name}"

Or in Java:

@WorkflowInterface
public interface MyWorkflow {
    @WorkflowMethod
    String run(String name);
}

🚀 Workflow Lifecycle

Started by a client or parent workflow
Executes workflow code
Calls activities asynchronously
May sleep, wait for signals, etc.
Completes, fails, or is cancelled
Execution history is recorded and can be replayed at any time

⚠️ Workflow Best Practices

✅ DO:

Use Temporal APIs: workflow.now(), workflow.sleep()
Keep workflows deterministic
Keep workflows orchestration-only (business logic in activities)

❌ AVOID:

Non-deterministic calls (random(), datetime.now(), external API calls)
Blocking I/O (use async)
Long-running operations inside the workflow (use activities instead)

💡 Workflow vs Activity

Feature	Workflow	Activity
State	Durable, replayed	Stateless, not replayed
Execution	Single-threaded, deterministic	Can be parallel, arbitrary code
Retry	Orchestrated by Temporal	Controlled via retry policy
Use Case	Orchestration	Actual work (I/O, DB, APIs)

Process Orchestrator, Spring Batch Application, and Microservices Architecture

🧩 1. Process Orchestrator

💡 What It Is:

A Process Orchestrator is a centralized system that manages, coordinates, and controls the execution of multiple services, tasks, or processes in a defined sequence.

🔧 Examples:

Temporal
Camunda
Apache Airflow
AWS Step Functions

✅ Strengths:

Visual and logical orchestration of tasks
Handles retries, timeouts, failures, and dependencies
Long-running workflows supported
Easy to monitor and audit process flows

🧠 Ideal For:

Complex business workflows
Coordinating across multiple services
Stateful, long-lived flows (e.g., order fulfillment, onboarding)

🧪 2. Spring Batch Application

💡 What It Is:

A Spring Batch Application is a Java-based framework for building batch processing jobs — often used for data transformation, ETL, or large-volume processing.

🔧 Key Features:

Job steps with readers, processors, writers
Retry, skip, and restart mechanisms
Handles large data volumes
Runs in-memory or can be persisted

✅ Strengths:

Optimized for throughput-heavy jobs
Mature ecosystem, integrates with Spring Boot
Declarative and configurable

🧠 Ideal For:

ETL jobs, database migrations
File processing, report generation
Scheduled data processing (e.g., every night at 2 AM)

🧱 3. Microservices Architecture

💡 What It Is:

An architectural style where an application is broken down into small, independent services that communicate over a network (usually via HTTP or messaging).

🔧 Characteristics:

Each service owns its own database and logic
Services are deployed independently
Communication via REST, gRPC, messaging (Kafka, RabbitMQ)

✅ Strengths:

Scalability (scale each service independently)
Resilience (failures isolated to services)
Flexibility in tech stack per service

🧠 Ideal For:

Large-scale applications with distributed teams
Need for high agility, frequent deployments
Applications with bounded contexts

🔍 Head-to-Head Comparison

Feature	Process Orchestrator	Spring Batch Application	Microservices Architecture
Primary Use Case	Long-running workflows	High-throughput data processing	Distributed, independent services
Handles State	✅ Yes	⚠️ Partially (with job persistence)	❌ Each service must manage its own
Parallelism / Concurrency	✅ Built-in	✅ Step-level parallelism	✅ Per service
Error Handling / Retries	✅ Built-in	✅ Configurable	❌ Must be implemented in each service
Best for Orchestration	✅ Yes	❌ No	⚠️ Requires manual implementation
Long-Running Tasks	✅ Yes	❌ No (typically short-lived jobs)	❌ Requires careful design
Workflow Visualization	✅ Yes (with tools like UI)	❌ No	❌ No built-in

🔧 How They Can Work Together

Use Spring Batch inside a microservice to perform batch jobs
Use a Process Orchestrator to coordinate multiple microservices or Spring Batch jobs
Combine Temporal with microservices to make fault-tolerant, distributed workflows

✅ Recommendation by Use Case

Use Case	Best Choice
Order processing across services	Process Orchestrator (e.g., Temporal)
Nightly ETL job	Spring Batch
Building an e-commerce platform	Microservices Architecture
Customer onboarding with approvals	Process Orchestrator
Migrating millions of records	Spring Batch

🪦 Digital Graveyard

Explorer

Temporal

Temporal

Overview

✅ 1. Multiple Components Running Across Nodes

✅ 2. Workflow Execution is Distributed

✅ 3. Resilient and Fault-Tolerant

✅ 4. Horizontal Scalability

✅ 5. Communication via Network Calls

In Summary:

Idempotency In Temporal

Concurrency in Temporal

Asynchrony in Temporal

Example (pseudo-code):

Determinism in Temporal

✅ Good (Deterministic) Workflow Example:

❌ Bad (Non-deterministic) Workflow Example:

🧠 How Temporal Enforces Determinism

💡 Key Sources of Non-Determinism to Avoid

🔐 How to Stay Deterministic

Summary

Workflow in Temporal?

🧠 Core Properties of Temporal Workflows

📦 What Workflows Can Do

🧱 Workflow Structure (High-Level)

🚀 Workflow Lifecycle

⚠️ Workflow Best Practices

💡 Workflow vs Activity

Process Orchestrator, Spring Batch Application, and Microservices Architecture

🧩 1. Process Orchestrator

💡 What It Is:

🔧 Examples:

✅ Strengths:

🧠 Ideal For:

🧪 2. Spring Batch Application

💡 What It Is:

🔧 Key Features:

✅ Strengths:

🧠 Ideal For:

🧱 3. Microservices Architecture

💡 What It Is:

🔧 Characteristics:

✅ Strengths:

🧠 Ideal For:

🔍 Head-to-Head Comparison

🔧 How They Can Work Together

✅ Recommendation by Use Case

Graph View

Table of Contents