How The Economic Machine Works

• The economy is a simple machine made up of transactions that drive economic activity.
• Transactions involve buyers exchanging money or credit for goods, services, or financial assets.
• The economy consists of markets where these transactions happen, and all players (people, businesses, banks, governments) engage in these exchanges.
• Credit is central to the economy; it allows spending beyond current income and drives economic activity.
• Borrowers use credit to buy things they can’t afford, and lenders make money by charging interest on the loans.
• Debt is created when credit is issued; it is an asset for lenders and a liability for borrowers.
• Spending drives the economy because one person’s spending becomes another person’s income.
• There are three primary forces that drive the economy:
  1. Productivity growth: Leads to long-term economic growth.
  2. Short-term debt cycle: Occurs in 5-8 years, driven by credit expansion and contraction.
  3. Long-term debt cycle: Occurs in 75-100 years, where growing debt burdens eventually cause a financial collapse.
• Credit enables people to borrow and spend more, leading to economic cycles.
• Short-term debt cycles result from fluctuations in credit availability, controlled by central banks adjusting interest rates.
• The long-term debt cycle involves the accumulation of debt, eventually leading to a crisis when debt burdens become unsustainable.
• Debt cycles are driven by human nature: people tend to borrow and spend more, even when it increases their debt.
• When credit becomes too excessive, the economy faces bubbles, where asset prices rise rapidly due to borrowing.
• Eventually, debt repayments grow faster than incomes, leading to a reversal of the cycle (recession or financial crash).
• The long-term debt cycle culminates in a deleveraging period, marked by falling incomes, rising debt repayments, asset sales, and economic contraction.

---

1. The Problem of Deleveraging:

   • Deleveraging occurs when borrowers (individuals, businesses, governments) struggle with unsustainable debt. The collapse of asset values and rising debt burdens leads to widespread defaults, slowing down the economy.
   • Unlike a typical recession where lowering interest rates can stimulate borrowing, in a deleveraging scenario, interest rates are already low (often near 0%) and are unable to reignite credit and borrowing.
   • The economy essentially becomes “not-creditworthy” because the debt is too large to be fully repaid.

2. Four Ways Debt Burdens Can Be Reduced:

   • Cutting spending: Borrowers (people, businesses, governments) try to reduce their debts by cutting back on their spending, often resulting in deflation and reduced economic activity.
   • Debt reduction (defaults and restructurings): When debts become unmanageable, defaults occur, and lenders agree to restructure the debt (lower amounts or longer repayment periods).
   • Wealth redistribution: Governments may raise taxes on the wealthy to redistribute wealth, aiding the “have-nots” who are struggling.
   • Money printing (inflationary solution): Central banks can print money to boost the economy, buying financial assets and government bonds, thereby increasing liquidity and asset prices.

3. Challenges of Deleveraging:

   • Austerity and deflation: Cutting spending to pay off debts can be harmful because it reduces income, leading to a vicious cycle where debts grow faster than they are paid off.
   • Debt restructuring: Reducing debts often leads to further economic contraction because both the asset values and incomes fall faster than debts are relieved.
   • Governments need to spend more (stimulus programs) to support the economy, but their revenue drops due to falling taxes, exacerbating deficits.

4. The Role of Central Banks and Governments:

   • Central Banks print money to stimulate economic activity, but this can lead to inflation if overdone. However, if managed correctly, printing money can offset the disappearance of credit and increase demand.
   • Governments use fiscal measures, such as stimulus spending and tax changes, to support the economy and redistribute wealth. This balance is necessary to avoid social and economic instability.

5. A Beautiful Deleveraging:

   • If policymakers manage the four solutions (spending cuts, debt reduction, wealth redistribution, money printing) carefully, they can stabilize the economy. In a “beautiful deleveraging”, debts fall relative to income, inflation remains in check, and real economic growth continues.
   • The ultimate goal is to have income growth outpace the interest on the debt, making debt burdens more manageable.
   • A “beautiful deleveraging” takes time (often over a decade) but can lead to long-term economic recovery and stability.

6. Key Takeaways:

   • Rule 1: Don’t allow debt to rise faster than income.
   • Rule 2: Don’t allow income to rise faster than productivity.
   • Rule 3: Focus on raising productivity to maintain competitiveness and sustainable growth.